Broker evaluation methodology: how and what we evaluate in a broker

Last updated Jun 11, 2024

Welcome to IamForexTrader.com - your independent source of information in investing and trading. We are professionals evaluating and comparing brokerage services across various market segments.

Our experts have evaluated and compiled reviews for over 100 brokers using an objective and transparent methodology. We deeply analyze each broker, studying everything from legal status and security to commissions, offered markets, products, analytics, and customer support levels.

Understanding the diverse needs of traders, we have compiled ratings for different categories of brokers: Forex and CFD, stock and futures brokers, and binary options brokers. We aim to help you navigate the vast array of offers and find the best broker.

At IamForexTrader.com, we strive to provide you with up-to-date, verified, and helpful information to help you make an informed choice and invest successfully.

Purpose of the Broker Evaluation Methodology

The broker evaluation methodology aims to provide an independent, objective, and transparent evaluation system that assists investors in making informed decisions when choosing a broker. The methodology seeks to account for all critical aspects of a broker's operation, including security, commissions, ease of account opening, the variety of offered markets and products, the quality of trading platforms, analytics, provided educational materials, and the level of technical support. This helps investors determine which broker best meets their requirements and expectations.

What Do We Evaluate in a Broker?

  1. Reliability and Regulation. We analyze the broker's legal status, the presence of licenses, and oversight by authoritative regulators. We check the investor protection guarantees and additional security measures offered.
  2. Account Opening. We open real accounts to assess the simplicity of the registration and verification process and the requirements for a minimum deposit. We note the necessary documents to complete the process.
  3. Account Types. We study the various account types offered by the broker. We evaluate each account type's trading conditions, minimum deposit requirements, tools, and services. Brokers providing more flexible and attractive conditions, including accounts for different levels of experience and trader preferences, receive a higher rating.
  4. Commissions. We gather information on all types of commissions: trading fees, non-trading fees, fees for deposits, withdrawals, and inactivity.
  5. Account Funding and Withdrawals. We evaluate available methods, costs, and the time required for deposits and withdrawals.
  6. Markets and Products. We analyze the number of available markets and products. Brokers with a broader range of products receive a higher rating.
  7. Trading Platforms. We test each trading platform, considering user-friendliness-specific features such as order placement, authentication options, and customization.
  8. Analytics. We check the broker's market analysis tools, looking for in-depth, unique, and valuable tools to help you gain insights into market trends, tickers, and companies.
  9. Education. We assess the quality of the offered educational materials. Brokers providing valuable and informative educational materials, including webinars, videos, podcasts, and articles, receive a higher rating.
  10. Technical Support. We test each specialized support channel, analyzing response speed, staff professionalism, and the effectiveness of provided solutions.

How is the Overall Broker Rating Compiled?

The overall broker rating is formed by considering all the listed parameters, each assigned a specific "weight" or degree of importance. Based on the ratings received for each parameter, we calculate the overall rating using the following weighting system:

  1. Reliability and Regulation: 15%
  2. Account Opening: 10%
  3. Account Types: 10%
  4. Commissions: 20%
  5. Account Funding and Withdrawals: 10%
  6. Markets and Products: 10%
  7. Trading Platforms: 10%
  8. Analytics: 5%
  9. Education: 5%
  10. Technical Support: 5%

The percentage allocation of each parameter was chosen considering their relative importance to the overall client experience. A broker's commissions undoubtedly play a significant role in the trader's overall cost structure, hence this parameter is given the most weight.

Broker Evaluation Process

  1. Preparation Stage. At this stage, we gather all available data about the broker. This includes information on the broker's website, client reviews, publicly available regulatory data, and other accessible sources.
  2. Data Analysis. Next, we analyze the collected data using our methodology. Each parameter is evaluated separately:
    • Reliability and Regulation. We check the broker's licenses and regulator information. We verify investor protection guarantees and other security measures.
    • Account Opening. We open a real account to check the process from start to finish.
    • Account Types. We examine the various account types the broker offers, their conditions, minimum deposits, and features. This allows us to see how flexible and adaptive a broker is to the needs of different categories of traders.
    • Commissions. We gather data on all fees related to trading and account management.
    • Account Funding and Withdrawals. We check the available deposit and withdrawal methods, cost, and transaction processing speed.
    • Markets and Products. We study which markets and products are available for trading.
    • Trading Platforms. We test the trading platforms offered by the broker.
    • Analytics. We examine the market analysis tools the broker offers.
    • Education. We assess the educational materials the broker offers.
    • Technical Support. We contact the support service to evaluate their accessibility, politeness, and problem-solving ability.
  3. Rating and Ranking. After evaluating each parameter, we apply the weights specified in our methodology to calculate the broker's overall rating. Brokers are then ranked according to their overall scores.
  4. Report. Finally, we compile a detailed analysis report, which includes our conclusions and recommendations. This report is then published on our website in the broker review.

Broker Rating Update

The rating update process includes the following stages:

  1. Monitoring Changes. We continuously monitor all evaluated brokers to track any changes in their services. This can consist of changes in fee structures, new products or services, regulatory changes, etc.
  2. Analysis of Changes. When we notice changes, we analyze them and determine how they might affect the broker's rating. In some cases, changes might be minor and don't require a rating update, while in others, they can significantly impact the broker's service quality.
  3. Updating Ratings. We update the broker's rating according to our methodology if the changes are significant enough to affect the rating. This might mean an increase or decrease in ratings in specific categories.
  4. Publication of Updated Ratings. After updating the ratings, we publish them on our website in the reviewed broker's overview. Updated ratings are accompanied by an explanation of why the rating was changed so our users can understand the reason for the changes.
  5. Periodic Review. We also conduct regular reviews of all ratings to ensure they remain current. As part of this review, we might re-analyze a broker, especially if a long time has passed since the last update or receive feedback from users pointing to potential issues.

This rating update process helps us ensure the timeliness and accuracy of our ratings, which is a crucial aspect of maintaining our users' trust.

Who Evaluates Brokers?

The IamForexTrader.com team works diligently daily to provide you with the most up-to-date and reliable information about brokers. Our team comprises seasoned professionals with deep knowledge and extensive experience in the financial sector.

We don't just evaluate brokers - we use their services and trade in the financial markets ourselves. This allows us to analyze the conditions offered by brokers and understand how these conditions work in practice. As a result, our reviews and ratings are based on experience, providing you with the most comprehensive and accurate information.

Disclaimer

We want to emphasize that the information and ratings provided on our website, IamForexTrader.com, are purely our advice and are not a guarantee of success in trading or investing. All materials are provided solely for informational purposes and should not be considered investment advice.

Financial markets carry a high level of risk, which can result in the loss of part or all of your invested capital. You should approach trading and investment strategies cautiously and ensure you fully understand and accept the potential risks.

While we make every effort to ensure the accuracy and timeliness of our information, errors and omissions can occur. We are not responsible for any losses or damages from using data from our website.

We strongly recommend that you consult with an independent financial advisor or use the services of a professional broker before making investment decisions.

Feedback

We value your thoughts and suggestions. Your feedback helps us refine our evaluation methodology and make iamforextrader.com even better.

If you have any comments, observations, or suggestions about our broker evaluation methodology, please don't hesitate to contact us at:

  • info@iamforextrader.com
  • adv@iamforextrader.com

We are always open to feedback and ready to consider your wishes in the further development of our website.

We urge you to assist us in making our service as helpful as possible for every user. Your reviews and opinions are crucial to us, and we are always eager to receive feedback from our readers.

You can leave your reviews and suggestions via email, through the feedback form on our website, or on social media. We will review each message and strive to respond as quickly as possible.

Thank you for your support and participation in improving IamForexTrader.com!